Protected by Copyscape DMCA Takedown Notice Violation Search

Wednesday, March 31, 2021

Book review: Raising a Humanist by Manisha Pathak-Shelat and Kiran Vinod Bhatia


I finally finished reading Raising a Humanist authored by a senior colleague in media education, Manisha Pathak-Shelat and my former student Kiran Bhatia over a week that has seen many of my extended family members and friends wracked by Covid19. The book has helped me cope through emotional upheaval this week and I am grateful to them for writing it. My three-year-old delightfully calls it “Manisha Aunty’s and Kiran’s purple book” and admiringly points to the pictures of the two authors on the back cover. They are also the only colour photographs in the whole book and hence grab the toddler’s attention when he is not clamouring for mine. Here’s my review below:

 

Book: Raising a Humanist – Conscious Parenting in an Increasingly Fragmented World

Authors: Manisha Pathak-Shelat and Kiran Vinod Bhatia

Pages: 240

Publisher: Sage Publishing

Price: Rs 495

One of the things that happen to you after becoming a mother is that you read all kinds of literature and watch numerous videos about parenting and how to raise kids. Often the how-to guides help but seldom delve deeper into the why, when, what, where and who. That’s where Raising a Humanist comes in. It describes the problems that parents encounter in an increasingly polarized and globalised world and then suggests solutions to the same without being preachy. The authors describe a child’s world view, how it is shaped by family, school and media. They talk about our echo chambers that operate around gender, religion, caste and class.

As you traverse through the pages, you start questioning your own philosophies and traditions, about how you and your family define and discriminate against the other gender, caste, creed, colour and religion. How many times have you consciously or sub-consciously shut your child out when you didn’t want to answer his/her questions? How many times have you chosen to ignore the fact that you’ve woken up early to make breakfast and tiffin for your family before dashing off to office while your spouse has spent his morning working out and reading a newspaper? How many times have you asked the maid to bring your child a glass of water or a spoon or search for something your child has misplaced instead of asking your child to do the same? How many times have you complained about reservations and then don’t want your child to play with others of economically and socially backward classes? How many times have you simply handed your mobile phone to your child so you could binge-watch your favourite show on an OTT platform? How many times have you taken your child out for dinner or ordered food just because you didn’t want to cook?

Raising a Humanist is a well-researched book packed with case studies, quotes, black and white illustrations, questions and exercises that makes you introspect about your identity, core beliefs and your idea of humanism and more importantly, if you’re willing to change them. It’s not just for parents, guardians, teachers or caregivers to know, but for every member of society, because whether you choose or not, you do come in contact with children and influence their lives directly or indirectly. The language is non-academic to allow for a lay reader to understand, though you might want to take breaks in your reading to ponder. While the book is primarily directed towards Indian parents, its wisdom can be shared across generations, borders, cultures, societies and languages. The authors write, “We must hold onto the last ounce of compassion and understanding in us as we create bridges and undo boundaries. We will encounter fear, threats, backlash and ridicule in our journey towards creating inclusive societies, but we can promise one thing. In the end, the struggle won’t be for nothing.” That’s a good reason to read this one.

 

Tuesday, March 30, 2021

Why I speak with my child only in English when he plays with poorer kids

The toddler saw three older girls in the society and ran towards them. All of them, daughters of maids, decided to play Ring-a Ring-a Roses with him. They started the rhyme but did not know beyond the first two lines. I completed it for them and they played thrice, while I sang and they joined in chorus. While my boy responds to four languages, I especially speak to him in English when he plays with kids from lower economic backgrounds, so that they too get a chance to learn the language, which otherwise they might have learned in school but because of Covid19 are not able  to. This gap in education and learning because of the pandemic has widened so much that it will take decades to get it back to what it was before Covid19 in third-world countries. Those who have the means can organise multiple language trainings online for their children. Those who don't are struggling with even their mother tongue. Try to include them in conversations so they learn another language as well. 

#languages #learning #informaleducation #english #COVID19

Sunday, March 28, 2021

Jobless Jackass Has Too Much On His Mind

Twin Soul Talks with Reagan Gavin and Eisha Sarkar: Telepathy

He: I think it's the telepathy thing. I know when you're feeling low
Me: Maybe
He: Really. I know
Me: Speaking of telepathy. If you look at Bombay Times and Downtown Plus from back in 2005, you'll see we covered the same celebs back to back. It was so bizarre that my colleague once commented, "Somebody upstairs thinks like you." Thankfully, we had a new editor who drove DTP to be a community magazine so I stopped interviewing celebs and covered communities instead. πŸ˜€πŸ˜€
He: It could have been because we covered the same events
Me: I got pulled up three times by the editor in 2008 when I just joined Mumbai Mirror because the Hollywood pages I made were identical to Bombay Times. And I was doing 6-8 pages a day! Of course, I had no idea that you were making the BT Hollywood pages. Same layouts too πŸ˜€ Thankfully, after a couple of weeks the page was handed over to someone else and they looked different from BT. πŸ˜€πŸ˜€πŸ˜€

#TwinSoulTalks #HimAndHer #telepathy #journalism


Saturday, March 27, 2021

Travel Talks with Reagan Gavin and Eisha Sarkar

He: I have never flown Economy, only Business in the last 10 years
Me: I flew Economy even when I was pregnant from Detroit to Paris to Mumbai in Air France. My parents were in Business. I had severe nausea, didn't eat
He: Why didn't you get an upgrade? You should have casually mentioned to the flight attendant that you are expecting .. you would have been transferred to business class in a snap of the finger
Me: Didn't want to sit with my parents. Inner peace πŸ™πŸ™πŸ™
He: In business you don’t need to sit with other people you have your own cabin. At least I had my stuff in Qatar and Emirates.
Me: Air France is not exactly Emirates
He: Qatar and Emirates and Singapore airlines are the best in the world. Air France is shit
Me: The characters you see at Charles de Gaulle in Paris will beat anything you've seen. I could spend years just sitting at that airport and drawing cartoons. πŸ˜€πŸ˜€πŸ˜€

#HimAndHer #airlines #flying #traveltalks #paris #qatar #airfrance #emirates #economy

Reagan Gavin

Wednesday, March 17, 2021

Where a small step in international relations unites a child and a mother

Through the last seven years, working in the field of #internationalrelations, I have realized that you don't necessarily have to be a part of a big #UN organisation or #NGO to make a difference to lives of people in other countries. Late last year, I got a message from my former #PaxPopuli colleague Tinku Gupta about an Afghan #refugee mother who escaped from her abusive husband in #Iran and fled to #Afghanistan. Unfortunately, her son was left behind and the husband, though willing to let go of her, did not want her to meet her son again. Tinku asked me for contacts in Iran. I was a bit skeptical about how much we could do, with borders closed because of Covid19. Iran was one of the worst hit last year and there's little data after the initial months. Still, I asked Behrad N. Mistry in Tehran for help, a man I know through a friend in #Pakistan and have never met. He pulled his network together, some lawyers too and coordinated with Tinku, while I stepped away busy playing mother to my toddler. Last week, Tinku texted me that the mother and son have been reunited. It made me feel happy to be a small part in a large chain of events that made mother and son unite.❤️

Saturday, March 13, 2021

Paid Internships Please for Arts, Liberal Arts, Communication and Social Work

#LongPostAlert #PaidInternshipsPlease

This one is a thorn in the Achilles' tendon. Year after year, I have had students in the fields of communication, social work, humanities, design and arts spend hours toiling at events or on projects that are organised or sponsored by industry, corporates and NGOs, without pay. Why? Because nobody has ever asked for it before. People are willing to pay management, tech, IT, engineering, accounts and medical interns (often a pittance but something) but not to those who are in the sphere of liberal and fine arts and development. Somewhere, as educators, we often side-step the issue in the classroom. We talk everything about the media, for example, except how much you should expect in an internship or a job. We assume students shall work for free, because, when we were students, we worked for free, right? And students, even when they earn internships in organizations which CAN pay, don't ask. Media organisations worldwide avoid the issue by saying they're giving a 'nobody' the 'exposure' he or she needs. In India, if you're lucky like me, you'll be 'allowed' to freelance for the media you had done your internship at and make some money after your internship. Bear in mind, this was for editorial interns in a newspaper. The marketing interns got their dough at the end of their internship. 

Over a period of time, I have realized that people pay when you ask them to pay for a job they want you to do. It maybe a mere Rs 100-500 a day for a communications intern at a global event but it is something. If you think that providing food and travel is enough to get you through an internship, well, let me tell you, even construction workers get that. At least ask for the minimum wage of Rs 176 a day. As for organizations, and especially those that have huge events that attract sponsors from everywhere, how about treating all your interns equally?

Friday, March 12, 2021

Animal Talks with Reagan Gavin and Eisha Sarkar: Why spiders are best

He: Nobody can f*** with you
Me: Relax, no one is
He: Not even a cockroach
Me: Okay, Pest Control!
He: I am serious
Me: What about spiders?
He: Spiders are good. They eat pests 
Me: πŸ˜€πŸ˜€πŸ˜€

#HimAndHer #AnimalTalks Reagan Gavin #pests

Thursday, March 11, 2021

How much to charge for transcription services in India: Writers and Journalists

#LongPostAlert #howtochargefortranscriptioninIndia #writers #journalists 

Taking off from my previous #longpost about how much freelance writers, photographers, artists, designers and editors should charge for their work in India, here's another guide to transcription. The current trend even for college research is to get all interviews on video. This creates a lot of footage that you have to sift through for research, quotes or data for your stories, books, infographics, etc. How do you know how much to charge when someone asks you for your transcription services? 10 minutes of video takes 50 minutes to an hour to transcribe. That is, if it's one single language. That means, you charge an hourly rate. Work it out. A 60 minute video will take you say at least six to seven hours to transcribe (I am talking about top-quality transcription). Maybe less, but you're a human so you need to take breaks for those aches. 

Most Indians, even on camera, speak a mix of two or three languages. There'll be English, some Hindi and a smattering of words from any of the regional languages. There maybe more. The more the languages you hear in the video, the more difficult it becomes to transcribe because the sound, words and tones keep changing. I am talking about only transcription here. You may transliterate or transcribe, as your role deems fit. The challenge is how long it will take to do that. If there's too much of Hinglish, bear in mind that you're transcribing two languages. It costs extra, depending on how long the tape and how much you have to strain. You could mark up 20-50%. 

Also, many clients want transcription done perfectly but in a hurry. If you can maintain quality and speed, you may very well get paid for it. Charge per hour you put in. It can be anywhere from Rs 800-2000 an hour depending on your experience. If, for some reason, you cannot tell a client how long it will take for you to do the transcription (as it happens with a lot of academic institutions, where you might have 50 two-hour videos to go through over months), either ask for a monthly fixed-rate or fix a rate for per hour of video, for example, for an hour's video footage, you charge about Rs 2000+. Again, I am talking about English-language transcription but I see no reason why you should be paid less in any other language. Institutions have budgets so they may not be willing to pay wholesome. Work with that. Quantify what you can deliver over a time period and create a payment schedule that keeps you and your morale afloat. I hope people who opt to outsource transcription services understand that there's a lot of work that goes into it and so they must pay.

Animal Talks with Reagan Gavin and Eisha Sarkar: Grin like a Shark

He: Your grin is like a shark's.
Me (taken aback): What!
He: No really. Great white's. You know, when I was in Miami, there were quite a few of them swimming around. 
Me: When you go snorkeling in the Barrier Reef in Australia, the guides tell you that if you spot a shark, you scatter and head for the boat.
He: Are there great whites in Australia?
Me: Yes, in the southern ocean. One reportedly swallowed an Australian Prime Minister
He (shocked): Did what?
Me: Yup. 1967, Australia's Prime Minister Harold Holt went swimming in Victoria and never came back.
He: πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚
Me: Shark tells her friends. "Guess what I had for lunch today?" πŸ˜€πŸ˜€πŸ˜€

#himandher #animaltalks #sharks #miami #australia Reagan Gavin #hownaturaliststalk

Wednesday, March 10, 2021

How much to charge for your creative: Writers, Photographers, Journalists, Designers, Artists

#LongPostAlert
Over the last decade or so of teaching students in the fields of communication, media, journalism, etc, I've had the same queries year after year from students, peers and friends who wish to spread their work far and wide but don't know how much to charge. To those of you who wish to get writers (all kinds, fiction/non-fiction, journalists) photographers, artists and designers to submit their work to you or "offer help" or "support you", you should PAY them for their help/support/job. They may be your best friends but they need a livelihood. As for how much should you pay or how should they charge you, here's a rough guide. Every organisation is different and will have their own budgets and goals but I am putting it down because I know people, even the most seasoned journalists, exploited by companies/NGOs and made to work for almost free because they found it "too awkward" to ask for money. Don't be. If you don't know how much you should charge, let this be a guide:
1. Cost per word/per article for writing: Most organisations will have a benchmark like Rs 300-500 for a 500 word piece. (Global organizations pay anywhere between Rs 2000-7000 for the same. You need to figure where you stand)
2. For photos published many organizations have a fixed rate per picture depending on the size of the pic used. But, nothing is for free. A thumbnail warrants at least Rs 100. If you've spent a whole day at a photo shoot with your equipment, break it down to hours, say Rs 500-1000+ an hour, depending on whether its a studio shoot, outdoor shoot, location, etc. Rented equipment is extra. Photo-processing, pre and post-production costs could be extra.
3. Editing: Most people still believe it's only about correcting grammar but it's not. If you are going to spend eight hours reading a 60000-word journal and then combing through it for days after that, at least get paid a rupee for each written word. Simple math: 60,000 words edit means you've got to rake in at least Rs 60000. If you're going to add a bit of design to the text, factor that in too. For websites, the same.
4. Design: This is the pain. Software is expensive and the clients can never figure what shade of blue they want. And Indian clients who aren't into publishing, just don't know what they should get and how much effort goes into it. Go by the number of pages for print. If it takes you say a couple of hours (over many days, maybe) to get what the client wants, quote by the hour. It could be anywhere from Rs 500/hour for a simple pamphlet to anywhere in the range of Rs 2000-5000 per hour for a digital on XD.

Of course, these are just ballpark figures and there maybe deviations across the country but it could be a starting point for both clients and creatives to know how much it costs. What I have written here is mostly English-language writing but I don't see why writing in any other language should mean that you get paid a pittance.

#howtochargeforcreativesinIndia #howmuchtopay

Animal Talks with Reagan Gavin and Eisha Sarkar: The Selfish Queen (in this case, a Mother-cat)

He: I pulled out frozen prawns from the fridge and gave them to the cat. Six fat prawns and she left her suckling kittens! Which mother does that? Leave your kids for food. So selfish!
Me: Well, fishes, reptiles and some birds. Maybe even sea horses
He (laughs): You hit my head with a baseball bat!



#animaltalks

Animal Talks with Reagan Gavin & Eisha Sarkar: Feeding Crows

He: Crows don't trust easily. You have to gain their trust otherwise they'll attack you
Me: A crow once attacked my mom and drew blood
He: That's what I am saying. Watch this 

(Shows me a live video of placing a spoon of pork fried rice on his palm. A crow swoops down to eat it.)
Me: Wow! Haven't seen that, ever.
He: It has taken months for me to gain their trust. Now watch.

(Places the rest of the rice on the balcony railing of his 250-year-old building. Crow sits next to it but doesn't eat.)
He: Eat, Donkey!
Me (laughing): Never heard anyone call a crow a donkey before πŸ˜€πŸ˜‚

#animaltalks #hownaturaliststalk #birds #birdfeeding #corvids

Jobless Jackass: Birthing Life